Skip to content
Udibo

Udibo vs Supabase Auth

Choose Supabase Auth when your data already lives in Supabase and SQL row-level security is your authorization model; choose Udibo to evaluate when you want hosted sign-in plus organizations and permissions checked by your backend. Supabase Auth is bundled with the database and includes 50,000 monthly active users on Free. Udibo provides an OAuth 2.0 identity service independent of your database, with exportable audit history.

Pricing, auth audit-log retention, SAML allowances, and email delivery checked November 15, 2026 against Supabase's pricing page and custom SMTP guide. Advanced MFA Phone and platform-access details were also checked November 15 against the phone MFA guide and platform access guide. Udibo's prices are on its pricing page.

Supabase's RBAC example, sign-in components, client architecture, and password migration documentation were checked November 19, 2026. Udibo usage assumptions and API access were reviewed October 2.

The short version

If you needStart with
Your data already in Supabase Postgres, with row-level security as the modelSupabase Auth
Organizations, invitations, and custom roles without designing the tablesUdibo
A permission checked on one resource, from a server outside Supabase's PostgresUdibo
Audit history you can export, on the free planUdibo
SAML single sign-on or phone-based MFA todaySupabase Auth on Pro/Team; Advanced MFA Phone add-on required for phone

Why teams pick Udibo over Supabase Auth

  • Organizations and roles are a product, not a schema. Supabase's own guide to role-based access has you create user_roles and role_permissions tables and write a Custom Access Token hook that copies the role into the JWT (Supabase RBAC guide). Udibo ships organizations with invitations, memberships, and roles on every plan, places no cap on organizations or members, and lets a person hold a different role in each. Supabase dashboard organization roles control access to project administration; product users and their roles are separate and can be modeled in your tables, token claims, and row-level security.

  • Permissions that follow the resource. Register the permission strings your application interprets, attach them to roles across a tenant, inside one organization, or on a single resource of your own. Tenant and active-organization permissions appear in the access token. To evaluate a grant on one resource, send the permission, resource type, and external ID to the hosted check. Row-level security answers the same question well when the data lives in Supabase's Postgres; when part of it lives somewhere else, the policy has to be rebuilt there.

  • Identity that does not move with the database. Your application talks to Udibo through OAuth 2.0 and OpenID Connect, with the active organization and its roles in the token. Use an OpenID Connect client that supports your application's flow. A shared protocol reduces sign-in coupling; changing provider still needs identity mapping, session changes, and a review of claims and permissions. Supabase Auth's tokens and the policies that read them are designed together: the strength while you stay, the cost when you go. Direct Custom OIDC token acceptance is not verified for Udibo; see the Supabase database FAQ. Udibo can still be integrated through your backend, which validates its token and applies your data-access rules.

  • A record you can take with you. At least 90 days of audit history on every plan, exportable as CSV or NDJSON. Supabase keeps auth audit logs for 24 hours on Free, 7 days on Pro, and 28 days on Team (checked November 15, 2026).

  • A bill about users, not the instance under them. Udibo's prices follow three things: retained users, hosted permission checks, and the email Udibo sends for you. Supabase Pro's $25 carries $10 a month in compute credits, enough for one Micro instance (shared compute, 1 GB); larger instances include Small at $15, 8XL at $1,870, and 16XL at $3,730 a month, with disk at $0.125 per GB past 8 GB and egress at $0.09 per GB past 250 GB. Whether Micro is enough depends on your database as much as your users, and the pricing page does not say.

  • Email you can ship with. Supabase's default sender delivers only to members of the project's team, with a limit of 2 messages per hour and no delivery SLA. Custom SMTP starts at 30 messages per hour and can be configured higher; Supabase recommends it for production and other recipients (Supabase custom SMTP, checked November 15, 2026). Udibo's Free plan includes 1,000 emails and Standard 10,000, then $1 per 1,000; email through your own sender is counted but never billed on either.

  • Sign-in pages you do not build, in your name. Udibo hosts sign-in and returns to your application, with your name, logo, and colors and no vendor badge on any plan. With Supabase Auth the sign-in form is code in your application, built from the client library or Supabase's UI blocks (Supabase UI: password-based auth).

Why Supabase Auth may still be the right choice

  • Your data is already there, and row-level security is the model. Policies are SQL on the table, auth.uid() and auth.jwt() are available inside them, and user-token requests are subject to RLS policies. A Supabase service-role-key request without a user access token bypasses RLS, so a backend making that request must enforce access itself (row-level security, checked November 15, 2026). Database, storage, realtime, and auth arrive in one console; Udibo is an identity service, and your data layer is yours to choose and run.

  • Far more users included. 50,000 monthly active users on Free and 100,000 on Pro for $25, then $0.00325 per MAU. Udibo's plans include 500 retained users on Free and 5,000 on Standard; at 100,000 users Supabase's listed auth price is $25 and Udibo's is about $290.

  • SAML and phone MFA today. Supabase offers SAML 2.0 single sign-on on Pro and Team, with 50 MAU included and $0.015 per additional MAU (checked November 15, 2026). Basic MFA is available on every Supabase plan. Udibo does not offer hosted SAML or phone MFA; its MFA is authenticator apps, passkeys, and recovery codes.

Pricing side by side

Supabase's pricing, auth audit-log retention, SAML allowances, and email delivery were checked November 15, 2026. Compute tier details and Udibo's pricing assumptions were reviewed October 2. The two count users differently: Supabase bills monthly active users; Udibo's pricing counts a retained user: "A person who returns more than 24 hours after creating their account counts once in that UTC calendar month."

You needUdiboSupabase
Free plan500 retained users, 25,000 hosted permission checks, 1,000 emails50,000 MAU; limit of 2 active projects, paused after 1 week of inactivity
First paid plan$5 a month plus usage: 5,000 users, 250,000 checks, 10,000 emails includedPro, from $25 a month: 100,000 MAU and $10 a month in compute credits (one Micro); Team from $599 a month
Multi-factor authenticationIncluded on Free (authenticator apps, passkeys, and recovery codes)Basic MFA on Free; Advanced MFA Phone is a paid add-on on Pro and Team (checked November 15, 2026)
Custom roles and permissionsIncluded on FreeTables and an auth hook you write; not a priced feature
Organizations and membersNo cap; invitations, memberships, and roles includedNot published as an Auth feature; modeled in your schema
Enterprise SSO connectionsNo per-connection fee for OpenID Connect providers; no SAMLSAML 2.0 not on Free; on Pro and Team, 50 MAU included, then $0.015 per MAU
Auth audit log historyAt least 90 days on every plan, exportable24 hours on Free, 7 days on Pro, 28 days on Team
Sign-in emailFree: 1,000 emails. Standard: 10,000, then $1 per 1,000; your own sender is counted but not billedDefault sender: team members only, 2 messages per hour and no SLA; custom SMTP starts at 30/hour, configurable, on every plan
Custom domainNot available$10 per domain per month per project
Users beyond the allowance$3 per 1,000 retained users$0.00325 per MAU past 100,000 on Pro
Hosted permission checksFree: 25,000 checks, refused past that. Standard: 250,000, then $10.00 per 1,000,000, only if you raise your checks limitNo equivalent product; row-level security runs inside your database

Three worked examples, with the same assumptions on both sides:

ScenarioUdiboSupabase
Consumer app: 10,000 users, 5,000 sign-in emails a month$20 (Standard base plus 5,000 users above allowance)$0 on Free for auth; email to customers requires a custom SMTP sender, whose cost is additional
B2B app: 200 users, organizations with custom roles, MFA on$0 on Free, or $5 on Standard$0 on Free for auth; organizations and roles are tables and an auth hook you build and maintain
Consumer app at 100,000 usersAbout $290$25 on Pro at the included ceiling, plus compute beyond the Micro credit if your project needs it

Sources: Supabase pricing, Supabase custom SMTP, and Udibo's pricing page. Both change; check the vendor's current page before you decide.

Cost at scale

Users only, assuming the same number of Supabase monthly active users and Udibo retained users. A first-day user can count for Supabase without counting for Udibo. These rows use Udibo Standard's prices and one Supabase Pro project; additional compute, email delivery, hosted permission checks, and other backend usage are outside the totals.

UsersUdiboSupabase Pro
1,000$5 (Standard)$25
10,000$20$25
100,000About $290$25
1,000,000About $2,990About $2,950 ($25 plus 900,000 × $0.00325)

Supabase's user price is close to Udibo's at a million users and far below it in between. What the table leaves out is the compute under those users: Pro's $25 covers one Micro instance, with larger listed sizes from $15 to $3,730 a month and custom capacity beyond that. Udibo's bill does not depend on a database tier.

What the integration looks like

With Udibo, register an application and its callback, send people to the hosted sign-in page, and finish the authorization-code flow on your server. Your backend holds the session and the browser gets a cookie, never a token. The first-login guide walks each checkpoint, and the organizations and permissions guides cover a person with a different role in each of two organizations. A role assigned on one resource is answered by the hosted check, not by the token.

With Supabase, the client library in your application signs people in and persists the tokens it is issued; the database enforces row-level security policies that read auth.uid() and auth.jwt() from that token (Supabase Auth, Supabase Auth architecture).

Neither approach removes your responsibility to protect application data: on Udibo it sits on your server, on Supabase in the policies on each table, and a permissive policy is a bug the login flow will not reveal.

Where Udibo needs a closer look

Udibo does not currently offer SAML, SCIM, phone-based MFA, or custom domains for its hosted pages. It is an identity service, not a backend platform: no hosted database, storage, or realtime, and no client that speaks Supabase's API. Customers administer tenants through the dashboard today; there is no self-serve management API credential for a script or backend. See the API guide. The @udibo/oauth2 package supplies protocol building blocks, not a hosted edition of the service. If a policy that matters today lives in SQL, test the whole journey through your backend before committing; a successful login alone does not establish parity.

Moving an existing Supabase application

Inventory row-level security policies, database functions, storage policies, realtime access, and every piece of code that assumes Supabase's JWT claims. Decide whether to keep your current data-access design with a supported identity integration or move access behind your backend, and verify that choice against the actual database configuration rather than the intended one.

Give your own user records stable IDs and record the mapping from the old issuer and subject to the new one; do not use email alone as an automatic account-linking rule. Test access with invalid, expired, and wrong-issuer tokens so a permissive policy does not become the shortcut that makes the new login appear to work. Password hashes in a supported format import and upgrade on first sign-in; MFA enrollment and sessions do not move, so plan a re-enrollment path. See migration planning and user import, and keep a tested denial path for every protected data surface. The directory export guide shows what you can download from a Udibo tenant after migration.

Try next: complete one Udibo login, then give a person two organizations and a different role in each, and check one from your own backend. Before you have an account, the agent integration brief lets your coding assistant prepare the integration.

Compare Firebase Authentication or browse the comparison index.

Frequently asked questions

Is Udibo cheaper than Supabase Auth? On users alone, no, until around a million. If your application already pays for a Supabase database, its auth is close to free. The comparison changes when the compute under your users has to grow to serve them, or when organizations, custom roles, MFA, and audit history are things you would otherwise build and operate in your schema.

Can I use Udibo with a Supabase database? Yes, through your backend: it validates Udibo's tokens and decides which records each request may read. If it queries Supabase with a secret/service-role key without a user access token, that request bypasses RLS, so the backend must enforce access itself (RLS service-role behavior, checked November 15, 2026). For direct Supabase Custom OIDC, the required singular role: authenticated claim is absent from Udibo's standard access token, so end-to-end compatibility is not verified. Supabase's Custom OIDC guide and Udibo's standard token claims were checked November 15, 2026; see the Udibo applications guide. Review the requirements and your row-level security policies before changing browser requests to a different issuer.

Does Udibo have row-level security? No. Your backend can ask Udibo whether the user has a permission on a specific record, then allow or deny the request. Your application enforces that decision when it reads or writes the row.

Can I move from Supabase Auth to Udibo? Supabase documents both its use of bcrypt and the export of auth records with password hashes. Udibo accepts canonical bcrypt hashes with cost factors 4 through 12 and upgrades them on the first successful password sign-in. It links social identities by subject. See migration planning and user import.

Last verified 2026-11-19.

View Markdown