Udibo vs Firebase Authentication
Choose Udibo when you need organization-scoped roles, per-resource permissions, hosted sign-in, MFA, and audit history without building them yourself. Choose Firebase Authentication when you need Firebase client SDKs and Security Rules, phone or anonymous sign-in, or Firebase's data services. Firebase email and social sign-in has no published user charge on its base tier; MFA and audit logging require Identity Platform, whose MAU charges depend on the product and usage.
Firebase and Identity Platform pricing, MFA, and activity limits checked November 15, 2026 against Identity Platform pricing, the Firebase Authentication overview, SMS MFA, TOTP MFA, and Firebase Auth limits. On November 19, 2026 we checked base sign-in pricing, operation limits, the client SDK and tenant model, Security Rules, and the SDK, session-cookie and password-format guides linked below. Udibo's prices are on its pricing page.
Additional details reviewed October 2, 2026: Udibo usage assumptions and API access, plus Firebase's federated-user limits, email quotas, and custom email delivery. Firebase's Admin SDK custom-token flow was checked November 15, 2026.
For another backend-platform option, see Amazon Cognito. The comparison index lists the other providers.
The short version
| If you need | Start with |
|---|---|
| A web or mobile app already on Firebase or Google Cloud, with Security Rules in play | Firebase Authentication |
| Base email and social sign-in with no separate per-user charge | Firebase Authentication |
| Phone sign-in, anonymous accounts, or a native mobile SDK | Firebase Authentication |
| Organizations, custom roles, and per-resource permissions checked from your backend | Udibo |
| Multi-factor authentication and audit history without an Identity Platform upgrade | Udibo |
| SAML at launch | Identity Platform, or another provider that ships it today |
Why teams pick Udibo over Firebase Authentication
Organizations are a product, not a pattern. With Firebase Authentication, model a customer's company and its members in application data. The custom claims payload for roles and other attributes is capped at 1,000 bytes. Udibo ships organizations with invitations, memberships, and roles on every plan, with no cap on organizations or members, and a person can hold a different role in each.
Permissions checked from the backend you run. Read tenant-wide and active-organization permissions from the Udibo access token. For a grant on a specific resource, call the hosted permission check over HTTPS. Firebase Security Rules decide access inside Firestore, Realtime Database, and Cloud Storage; a backend elsewhere gets an ID token and custom claims. If the identity starts outside Firebase, your server can mint a Firebase custom token for that user; the client exchanges it for a Firebase ID token. You still define how that mapped Firebase identity reaches your data and permissions.
MFA and audit history on Free. Firebase requires the Identity Platform upgrade for SMS or TOTP MFA and audit logging. The upgrade automatically enables admin activity logging; user activity logging is optional. Identity Platform's email/social MAU allowance is 50,000 before user charges, while other products and usage can be billed separately. On Spark, the daily limits are 3,000 active users for Tier 1 providers such as email and social sign-in, and 2 for Tier 2 providers (SAML and OpenID Connect). These are daily active user (DAU) limits. Udibo's Free plan includes authenticator-app and passkey MFA with recovery codes and at least 90 days of audit history exportable as CSV or NDJSON.
Federated users cost the same as everyone else. Identity Platform bills SAML and OpenID Connect users at $0.015 per monthly active user after the first 50 per project, about $15 per 1,000. Udibo connects any OpenID Connect provider with no per-connection fee, and a federated user is a retained user at the same $3 per 1,000 as any other. SAML is not available on Udibo today.
A standards boundary instead of a client library per platform. Your application talks to Udibo through OAuth 2.0 and OpenID Connect, with the active organization and its roles in the token. Use an OpenID Connect client that supports your application's flow. A shared protocol reduces sign-in coupling; changing provider still needs identity mapping, session changes, and a review of claims and permissions.
Your brand on the pages you did not build. Udibo hosts the sign-in, recovery, and MFA pages with your name, logo, and colors and no vendor badge on any plan. Firebase leaves the sign-in page to you. Its Google-sent templates let you change the sender, reply-to, and subject, but the message body only for password resets. For fully custom verification and sign-in messages, use Admin SDK action links with your own email service; you build and send those messages.
Lower user-only costs in the larger scenarios below. Identity Platform charges $0.0055 per monthly active user from 50,000 to 100,000 and $0.0046 from there to 1,000,000; Udibo's rate is $3 per 1,000 retained users. At 1,000,000 users that is $4,415 against about $2,990, before other usage. Identity Platform's email and social sign-in user allowance is 50,000; Udibo is also free within 500 retained users and its other Free allowances.
Why Firebase Authentication may still be the right choice
Base sign-in without a per-user charge. Email, social, anonymous, and custom sign-in are included on both the Spark and Blaze plans, and the pricing page lists no monthly active user charge for them unless a project upgrades to Identity Platform. Account creation, email delivery and SMS have separate limits, and phone sign-in is billed per message.
Client SDKs and the Firebase data model. Firebase's SDKs for web, Apple, Android, C++, and Unity sign people in from inside the app, and Firestore, Realtime Database, and Cloud Storage trust the result through Security Rules. Udibo has no mobile SDK, and its tokens do not drive Security Rules.
Phone and anonymous sign-in. Firebase offers phone sign-in on the Blaze plan, billed per SMS, and anonymous accounts that can be upgraded later. Udibo offers neither today.
SAML, blocking functions, and tenants. Identity Platform adds SAML (web only), functions that run before registration and sign-in complete, and tenants that silo users and configuration within one project. Udibo does not offer SAML or SCIM.
Pricing side by side
Firebase and Identity Platform pricing, MFA, and limits were checked November 15, 2026, with base sign-in pricing and limits rechecked November 19. Udibo's pricing assumptions were reviewed October 2. The two count people differently: Identity Platform bills a monthly active user, "any account that has signed in within a given month", and Udibo prices a retained user: "A person who returns more than 24 hours after creating their account counts once in that UTC calendar month." The examples below assume every person counted is active that month on both sides.
| You need | Udibo | Firebase Authentication |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | 500 retained users, 25,000 hosted permission checks, 1,000 emails | Base Spark: email, social, anonymous, and custom sign-in with no user charge listed; phone sign-in "not applicable". Firebase Authentication upgraded with Identity Platform on Spark: daily limits of 3,000 Tier 1 DAU and 2 Tier 2 DAU (limits) |
| First paid plan | $5 a month plus usage: 5,000 users, 250,000 checks, 10,000 emails included | Blaze, pay as you go, no plan fee published; with Identity Platform, first 50,000 email/social MAUs and 50 SAML/OIDC MAUs are free, then priced by MAU; phone and SMS MFA are priced per SMS (rates) |
| Multi-factor authentication | Included on Free; authenticator apps, passkeys, and recovery codes | SMS and TOTP require Identity Platform; SMS is free for the first 10 sent per day, then the listed per-message rates apply (SMS MFA, rates) |
| Custom roles and permissions | Included on Free | Custom claims set by the Admin SDK, up to 1,000 bytes per user (docs); roles, organizations, and per-resource checks are yours to build |
| Organizations and members | No cap | Model product memberships in application data. Identity Platform tenants isolate users and configuration within a project |
| Remove vendor branding | Included on Free: your name on hosted pages and in email content; mail comes from your domain once you connect your own sender | No hosted sign-in page to brand; Google-sent templates allow body changes for password resets only. Fully custom emails use Admin SDK links and your own sender |
| Custom session lifetime | Included on Free | Session cookies from 5 minutes to 2 weeks through the Admin SDK (docs) |
| Enterprise SSO connections | No per-connection fee for OpenID Connect providers; no SAML | Identity Platform: SAML (web only) and OpenID Connect at $0.015 per monthly active user after 50 free per project; no per-connection fee published |
| Audit or application log history | At least 90 days on every plan | Identity Platform: admin activity logs in Cloud Logging, user activity logging optional; not listed for the base product |
| Sign-in email | Free: 1,000 emails. Standard: 10,000, then $1 per 1,000; your own sender is counted but not billed | No email charge listed; sender domain customizable after verification. Published email-link sending limits: 5/day on Spark, 25,000/day on Blaze |
| Phone sign-in | Not offered | Blaze only; first 10 SMS sent per day are free, then $0.01 each in the US and Canada and $0.07 in India (rates) |
| Users beyond the allowance | $3 per 1,000 retained users | Base product: no user charge listed. Identity Platform: $0.0055 per monthly active user from 50,000 to 100,000, $0.0046 to 1,000,000, $0.0032 to 10,000,000, $0.0025 above |
| Hosted permission checks | Free: 25,000 checks, refused past that. Standard: 250,000, then $10.00 per 1,000,000, only if you raise your checks limit | No equivalent; Security Rules evaluate inside Firebase's own databases and storage |
Three worked examples, with the same assumptions on both sides:
| Scenario | Udibo | Firebase Authentication |
|---|---|---|
| Consumer app: 10,000 retained users, 5,000 sign-in emails, TOTP MFA, your own branding | $20 (Standard base plus 5,000 users above allowance) | $0 user charge (10,000 MAUs are within Identity Platform's 50,000 Tier 1 allowance; TOTP requires the upgrade but has no SMS charge) |
| B2B app: 200 users, 5 organizations of 30 members, custom roles, TOTP MFA | $0 on Free, or $5 on Standard | $0 user charge (200 MAUs are within the Identity Platform allowance) plus the organization and role model you build on custom claims |
| App at 100,000 users with MFA | About $290 | $275 (50,000 monthly active users at $0.0055 on Identity Platform), plus per-message SMS if the second factor is SMS |
The 5,000-email scenario assumes Blaze: Google's Spark plan sends at most 5 email-link sign-in messages a day. The $0 figures do not include an external email service for fully custom messages.
Sources: Firebase pricing, Identity Platform pricing, Firebase custom tokens, and the Firebase Authentication overview for what the upgrade adds and its Spark limit, and Udibo's pricing page. All change; check the vendor's current page before you decide.
Cost at scale
Users only, on the plan that gives you MFA, assuming every person counted is active that month on both sides. Udibo's figures are its published rates; Firebase's are Identity Platform's published tiers on the Blaze plan, priced band by band the way Google's own pricing examples do.
| Users | Udibo | Firebase with Identity Platform |
|---|---|---|
| 1,000 | $5 (Standard) | $0 |
| 10,000 | $20 | $0 |
| 100,000 | About $290 | $275 |
| 1,000,000 | About $2,990 | $4,415 |
Without the Identity Platform upgrade, Firebase publishes no per-user charge for base email and social sign-in. Operation and email quotas still apply. Udibo also has no charge within 500 retained users and its other Free allowances, then prices usage on Standard.
For email and social sign-in on Identity Platform, the first 50,000 monthly active users have no user charge. Comparing the same user counts on both sides, the user-only bills are close at 100,000, and Udibo Standard becomes lower at roughly 110,000 through the 1,000,000-user scenario shown above. These are user-only comparisons, not total bills or a claim about every higher tier. Federated users have a separate rate: 10,000 OpenID Connect users cost about $149 a month on Identity Platform and $20 on Udibo, when tenant-wide sign-in options fit your application. Email and other services can change the complete cost.
What the integration looks like
With Udibo, register an application and its callback, send people to the hosted sign-in page, and finish the authorization-code flow on your server. Your backend holds the session and the browser gets a cookie, never a token. The first-login guide walks each checkpoint, and the organizations and permissions guides cover a person with a different role in each of two organizations.
With Firebase, the client SDK signs people in from inside your app and hands back an ID token that Firestore, Realtime Database, and Cloud Storage trust through Security Rules; a backend elsewhere verifies it with the Admin SDK (verify ID tokens). For identity established outside Firebase, your server can mint a Firebase custom token and the client exchanges it for a Firebase ID token that Security Rules can evaluate (custom tokens). This bridges a mapped user into Firebase; it does not make Security Rules trust the external provider's token directly. FirebaseUI is Firebase's drop-in UI for the common sign-in methods (FirebaseUI).
A Firebase client often uses identity in more places than the login screen. Before comparing providers, list the database, storage, and server endpoints that trust the current user. Udibo's hosted flow gives your application identity through OAuth 2.0 and OpenID Connect, and your backend applies the organization and resource checks; nothing translates those checks into Security Rules. A valid session says who someone is; your backend still decides what they may read.
Where Udibo needs a closer look
Udibo does not currently offer SAML, SCIM, phone sign-in, or anonymous
accounts, and there is no mobile SDK. Udibo Identity sign-in uses hosted pages
and redirects rather than embedded components. The @udibo/oauth2 package
includes optional, unstyled React forms for applications using their own
authorization server; those forms do not embed Udibo Identity's hosted sign-in.
Customers administer tenants through the dashboard today; there is no self-serve
management API credential for a script or backend. See the
API guide. If
anonymous-to-registered upgrades, phone sign-in, mobile recovery, or a Security
Rule that depends on the signed-in user is essential, demonstrate the complete
target workflow before committing; a successful login alone does not establish
parity.
Moving an existing Firebase application
Inventory anonymous users, linked providers, custom claims, Security Rules, and code that assumes a Firebase UID. Keep your application's stable user ID and record the mapping from the old issuer and subject to the new one; do not use email alone as an automatic account-linking rule. Test every Security Rule and backend verifier affected by a new token, and do not weaken a rule to make a different issuer's token appear valid. Firebase uses modified scrypt for its native password hashes. Udibo's importer requires a supported encoding. Offer a reset or operate a password migration endpoint that can check the old password. Existing sessions and MFA enrollment do not move with a profile. See migration planning.
If you later leave Udibo, the Udibo export guide explains what you can take with you.
Try next: complete one Udibo login, then give a person two organizations and a different role in each. Before you have an account, the agent integration brief lets your coding assistant prepare the integration.
Frequently asked questions
Is Udibo cheaper than Firebase Authentication? On user charges alone, both can cost $0 for a small app within Udibo's 500 retained users and other Free allowances. Firebase's base email and social sign-in have no published user charge; Identity Platform includes the first 50,000 email/social monthly active users. From 501 through 50,000 retained users, Udibo Standard's user-only price is $5 to about $140, assuming other usage fits its allowances. Udibo includes organizations, roles, resource permissions, MFA, and audit history that you would otherwise assemble around Firebase. For Identity Platform's email and social sign-in, the equal-user-count examples above favor Udibo from roughly 110,000 through 1,000,000 users; OpenID Connect federation uses a separate rate. Add email, hosted permission checks, SMS, and other services before comparing the complete bill.
Does Udibo have client SDKs and phone sign-in like Firebase? No. Udibo hosts the sign-in, recovery, and MFA pages and returns to your app through OAuth 2.0; there is no mobile SDK, no UI kit, and no phone or anonymous sign-in. Choose an OpenID Connect client library that supports your application type and callback flow, and test that complete journey. The account screens inside your product are yours to build.
Can I move from Firebase to Udibo without making users re-register? Profiles and social identities can be imported and linked by the provider's stable subject. For passwords stored with Firebase's modified scrypt, offer a reset or check the old password through your migration endpoint. MFA enrollments, anonymous accounts, and active sessions do not move. See migration planning and user import.
Do I need Identity Platform for MFA on Firebase? Yes. Firebase documents SMS and TOTP multi-factor authentication for projects upgraded to Firebase Authentication with Identity Platform. Email/social MAU charges start past 50,000 on Blaze; SAML and OpenID Connect have a separate allowance and rate. Spark's daily limits are 3,000 Tier 1 active users and 2 SAML/OpenID Connect active users. Udibo includes authenticator-app and passkey MFA with recovery codes on Free and does not offer SMS factors.
Last verified 2026-11-19.

